GGOATRANK

🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 England — Premier League / First Division

England's greatest club of all time, scored on domestic titles, continental record, era dominance and longevity.

Quick answer

According to GOAT Rank's current model, Manchester United is the highest-ranked of 5 tracked teams in the Premier League, with a Team GOAT Score of 93.5.

How the GOAT Score is calculated →
Get pings

GOAT Rank verdict

Manchester United edge Liverpool on all-time English dominance

Liverpool own the European record, but on the GOAT Rank weighting — domestic titles, modern-era dominance, continuity and reach — Manchester United take first place in England.

Manchester United crest

Framework leader

Manchester United
93.5
Liverpool crest

Closest challenger

Liverpool
92.4
  • Domestic titles

    Manchester United 20 league titles (record) vs Liverpool 19. United hold 13 of the 33 Premier League titles.

  • European record

    Liverpool lead clearly: 6 European Cups/Champions Leagues (English record) vs United's 3, plus more European finals.

  • Cups

    United 13 FA Cups and a Club World Cup; Liverpool 8 FA Cups and a record 10 League Cups; Arsenal lead the FA Cup with 14.

  • Era dominance

    The Ferguson era delivered 13 titles in 21 seasons — the deepest sustained run of the modern English game.

  • Challengers

    Arsenal add The Invincibles and 13 titles; Manchester City's 2010s–2020s peak is the highest single-era rating in the dataset.

Result of the GOAT Rank weighted model (dominance, peak, longevity, honours, statistics), not an absolute fact. Title counts are dataset totals. Sources: Premier League, The FA, UEFA, RSSSF. Methodology

#1Manchester United crest
🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 Manchester United

A record 20 English titles, 13 Premier League crowns and the 1999 treble.

  • Champions League3
  • Domestic league20
  • Domestic cup13
93.5
Compare
#2Liverpool crest
🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 Liverpool

England's European record-holder: six European Cups and 19 league titles.

  • European Cup / UCL6
  • League titles19
  • FA Cup8
92.4
Compare
#3Arsenal crest
🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 Arsenal

The Invincibles: an unbeaten Premier League season and 14 FA Cups.

  • League titles13
  • FA Cup14
  • League Cup2
84.2
Compare
#TeamKey titlesTeam GOATActions
410 League titles · 1 Champions League · 7 FA Cup84.1
56 League titles · 2 Champions League · 8 FA Cup80.6
Follow

All club crests, team names and trademarks belong to their respective rights holders and are shown solely for identifying, editorial and analytical purposes (nominative fair use).

Some links to club shops are affiliate links. If you buy something through them, GOAT Rank may earn a commission. This never affects rankings, scores or editorial judgements.