League MVP awards
3
Provincial league titles
2
Professional seasons
11
Hall of Fame inductions
1
All-star selections
4
Category profile
- Dominance
- 78
- Peak
- 88
- Longevity
- 76
- Honours
- 82
- Statistics
- 84
Career timeline · Form index per season
Editorial season form index (0–100), not raw goals or points. Raw season-by-season statistics are shown only where fully verified.
| Season | Form index per season | Share of career |
|---|---|---|
| 1944 | 55 | |
| 1945 | 62 | |
| 1946 | 70 | |
| 1947 | 77 | |
| 1948 | 85 | |
| 1949 | 92 | |
| 1950 | 84 | |
| 1951 | 75 | |
| 1952 | 67 | |
| 1953 | 58 | |
| 1954 | 50 |
Data sources
- NHL official records
- Hockey Hall of Fame
- Hockey-Reference
Last verified: 2026-09-14
Figures come from public records and are normalised per sport. See the methodology for category weights. Method
Why Herb Carnegie ranks #270 in Ice Hockey
Herb Carnegie ranks #270 in Ice Hockey and #3091 of 5087 across all sports. The verified GOAT Score is 81.3/100.
The verified career covers 1944–1954 and 11 documented seasons. Peak is 88/100, with Peak the strongest category at 88/100 (20% weight). Key metrics: League MVP awards 3, Provincial league titles 2, Professional seasons 11, Hall of Fame inductions 1.
Nearest context: ahead Lynn Patrick (81.3); behind Red Horner (81.2). Rankings update whenever verified records change.
Herb Carnegie GOAT Score explained
- Dominance78/100 · weight 25%
- Dominance: 78/100, based on the verified career record.
- Peak88/100 · weight 20%
- Peak: 88/100, based on the verified career record.
- Longevity76/100 · weight 20%
- Longevity: 76/100, based on the verified career record.
- Honours82/100 · weight 20%
- Honours: 82/100, based on the verified career record.
- Statistics84/100 · weight 15%
- Statistics: 84/100, based on the verified career record.
Top Carnegie comparisons
Herb Carnegie — frequently asked
- Is Herb Carnegie the GOAT?
- According to GOAT Rank's current data model, Herb Carnegie ranks #270 in Ice Hockey with a GOAT Score of 81.3/100, behind Wayne Gretzky (97.8).
- What is Herb Carnegie's GOAT Score?
- 81.3/100, calculated from the verified career record: Dominance 78 (25%), Peak 88 (20%), Longevity 76 (20%), Honours 82 (20%), Statistics 84 (15%).
- Where does Herb Carnegie rank all time?
- #3091 of 5087 eligible athletes across all sports and #270 in Ice Hockey.
- Herb Carnegie vs Lynn Patrick: who ranks higher?
- Herb Carnegie ranks higher at 81.3 versus Lynn Patrick at 81.3, a margin of 0.0 points.